NDTV Search
Review : Kaminey
(Action/Drama)
Anupama Chopra, Consulting Editor, Films, NDTV
Friday, August 14, 2009
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend Print A+   A-
Kaminey
Cast: Shahid Kapoor, Priyanka Chopra, Amol Gupte, Deb Mukherjee, Rajatabha Dutta, Harish Khanna, Carlos Paca, Chandan Roy Sanyal, Tenzing Nima, Shiv Subrahmanyam, Hrishikesh Joshi
Music: Vishal Bhardwaj
Director: Vishal Bhardwaj
Producer: Ronnie Screwvala
Writer: Vishal Bhardwaj

Special:Kaminey

Kaminey is the best Bollywood film I’ve seen this year. It’s an audacious, original rollercoaster ride. Written and directed by Vishal Bharadwaj, Kaminey requires patience and attention but the pay off is more than worth it.

Kaminey is about Charlie and Guddu, twin brothers played by Shahid Kapoor, both of whom suffer from speech impediments and who can’t stand the sight of each other. Charlie, who pronounces S as F, is a small time gangster. Guddu, who stammers, is a mousy NGO worker. Guddu’s life plans, chalked out until 2014 on a chart stuck in his cupboard, are wrecked when he impregnates Sweety, his fiery girlfriend who until now has neglected to tell him that she is the sister of a powerful gangster-politician, Bhope, played by Amol Gupte. Meanwhile Charlie has come to possess a guitar containing cocaine worth 10 crore. The quintessential gambler thinks he’s finally hit the big score. What follows is a frantic, convoluted journey through Mumbai’s mean streets which are of course populated by many Kamineys: corrupt cops, nasty drug dealers, gun wielding henchmen. Eventually, the brothers’ determinedly separate narratives collide and they are forced to come together.

Be warned: there are stretches of Kaminey that will thoroughly confuse you, starting with the first fifteen minutes. The film has eleven-odd characters that you need to keep track of. Snatches of dialogue are in Bengali and Marathi. If you look away from the screen to send a text message, you might miss another twist in this very, very tangled tale. The first half moves slowly. You might be bewildered and perhaps even bored. But stay with the film. Because the pacing picks up in the second half and Vishal ties up the threads in an exhilarating climax, which, incredibly enough, manages to combine stunning violence with humor.

Kaminey is that rarest of things: an unpredictable Hindi movie. Vishal, referencing the crackling gangster dramas of Quentin Tarantino and Guy Ritchie, keeps it gritty and dark. Violence looms large over Kaminey but the tension is layered with black humor. The film reworks Hindi cinema’s favorite formula - twins - into a bloody theater of the absurd. Charlie and Guddu are unlike any twins you’ve seen before. Each one is willing to sacrifice the other to get what he wants. This is the role or roles of a lifetime and Shahid Kapoor, best known for innocuous chocolate-boy romances, sinks his teeth in. Kaminey does for him what Omkara did for Saif Ali Khan. A star has evolved into an actor.

Sweety is this year’s most exciting heroine after Paro in Dev D, and Priyanka plays her with aplomb. Only her perfectly manicured nails struck me as out of synch with her character. Vishal has equal affection for the smaller players: from the coke-addled Mikhail played nicely by Chandan Roy Sanyal to the Jai Maharashtra-spouting Bhope. Each one is flesh and blood.

Kaminey will take some getting used to. It isn’t the comfort food that Bollywood normally dishes out. But I strongly recommend that you see it. This taste is worth acquiring.



Watch video:

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend Print | A+   A-
Post your reviews
Name:*   E-mail:*
Comments:* 2000 characters remaining
 
Spam protection
Enter the code:*
Disclaimer: Material sent in this section is contributed by users. Ndtvmovies accepts no responsibility for the content or accuracy of such material and does not endorse or subscribe to the content.
User reviews


Posted by:  gokul  [ Monday, August 24, 2009 2:52 PM ]
Another Average movie hyped by media....!!!! Mindless...absolutely. The maker of Maqbool, Blue Umbrella and Omkara cannot make this unbelievable disaster....

Posted by:  svindia  [ Sunday, August 23, 2009 10:09 PM ]
I would rate this movie 4 out of 5. A+. This movie brings Hollywood style experience and feel to a Bollywood Movie. It may not impress everyone, but must appreciate Shaahid Kapoor's acting. Many would have thought, he can not do such serious roles but he has proved that Baap Nabari to Beta Das Numbari.

Posted by:  max  [ Sunday, August 23, 2009 9:13 PM ]
i will agree that its a good movie.But there is nothing so 'kaminey ish' about the hero.I mean he is a average gangster..he is not even shown as being ruthless and all.If you have seen the tamil filim 'pudhupetai' (selvaragavan,dhanush)..you will know what i mean.apart from that, its a decent movie, i mean, if you can follow the story.It could have been much better though....

Posted by:  Abhilash  [ Sunday, August 23, 2009 12:04 AM ]
'Kaminey' is a well directed movie with gutsy performances from almost the entire cast. But sadly, the idea was not original. Inspired mainly by Guy Ritchie's 'Snatch' and 'Lock stock and two smoking barrels'. This movie is not really upto that level. But certianly a good watch on a weekend. But this will go a long way to help Shahid, priyanka's careers. I could understand the fact that a lot of our audiences who are obssesed with karan johar's mushy romances and ram gopal verma's mindless violences cant comprehend some intelligent cinema. We need to keep our creative box open ! Hoping for more good movies and more original ideas from Bharadwaj ! Kudos!

Posted by:  Priti  [ Saturday, August 22, 2009 11:15 AM ]
awsum film....its a must watch...sahid is so gud in d movie.....i njust luv u sahid. loking so gud with priyankaji..i luv u .....sahid...n u look so sweet n cool wid ur new hair style

Posted by:  kuckeee  [ Saturday, August 22, 2009 10:33 AM ]
fantabulous..mindblowing...superb film...excellent direction..excellent charcters...film rocks man!!! Super duper hit..no matter what saif tried...film made a bigger hit than love aaj kal......

Posted by:  king  [ Thursday, August 20, 2009 11:30 PM ]
KAMINEY IS A AWESOME... A CULT FILM IN BOLLYWOOD... WATCH IT AND ENJOY!! SHAHID ROCK... AND PRIYANKA IS DAMN COOL!!! SERIOUSLY WATCH IT...MIND BLOWING MOVIE!!!!

Posted by:  lilycircus  [ Thursday, August 20, 2009 12:55 PM ]
kaminey is a lousy movie , the type of which i have not seen for long time. i have gone with my family to have a ball of time and lo what is dished out was abscenely horendous movie.there is nothing for family people to crave in that movie.dark and murky surroundings,hideous characters of our society, oh!! what atrash of movie. after JAB WE MET, we expected a lot from shahid but he let us down badly.looks like vishalbhardwaj want to take revenge on movie goers.

Posted by:  sunny sharma  [ Thursday, August 20, 2009 4:25 AM ]
If you didn't like this movie then there is something seriously wrong with your sensibilities atleast as far as watching and appreciating a brilliant movie like goes. Kaminey is not just a good crime drama, it is probably the finest movie this industy has managed to churn out. there are many departments where this movie excels for starters the cinematography is original and enigmatic, the screeplay is written to perfection , the stunts and action is real, the dialogues make you laugh without ever trying to, and the direction and acting is par excellence. Comparing it to movies of tarantino and guy ritchie is probably unfair and rightly so because this movie outshines some of their work also. this is one movie where i didnt want the movie to end beacuse i was loving the ride. hopefully the future of bollywood will be held in the hands of talented directors and actors that this movie boasts of.....every character comes alive on the screen.Latsly the movie does more than just live upto your expectations....and is a must watch for every film lover or otherwise.......

Posted by:  anupam  [ Wednesday, August 19, 2009 2:12 PM ]
Who is this adi who's posted d worst comment ive ever heard...Mr Adi, I am sure u have not seen a single Quentin Tarantino movie if you say Sanjay Gupta is a good filmmaker.Blatantly lifting story and screenplay from 2 movies n putting together 1 movie called Kaante isnt filmmaking (Usual Suspects +Resevoir Dogs=kaante) So pls pls if u think ur a movie buff watch more movies before u pass judgements on sincere efforts. Reviewers arent comparing it to QT movies coz of the chaos n non linear timelines, they r doing so coz the essence of filmmaking is the same. From the quirky characters to putting songs/soundtracks at the unlikiliest of places, to having a constant undercurrent of black humor thruout the running time. And most of all, to making us believe that these ppl live in some parallel universe. U may have ur opinion n u may not like it but to say sanjay gupta n other unoriginal filmmakers (like Aproova Lakhia) are better than Vishal (who has had briilliant takes on very different stories) is akin to blasphemy.. So pls understand movies before u talk abt them.

Posted by:  Praveen  [ Wednesday, August 19, 2009 12:26 PM ]
Kaminey is the worst Bollywood film I’ve seen this year.

Posted by:  ravi prakash  [ Wednesday, August 19, 2009 12:32 AM ]
Kaminey once again establish vishal as one of the best directors of our time.Kaminey shows the effect of gritty direction,tight and powerful performance.Film will work more for Shahid , Priyanka,Chandan gupta and Amol gupte than for Vishal and Gulzar,for obvious reasons.Not to forget Vishal's music score,which is again of top quality. Unfortunately,he is not getting enough recognition as a music director. Although Maqbool is still Vishal's best work,Kaminey suits his portfolio.well done Vishal and Co.Keep going.

Posted by:  Adi  [ Monday, August 17, 2009 8:25 AM ]
Vishal Bharadwaj failed this time. Its a different action drama, but it is an average movie. The fact that Indian movie critics came up with almost similar reviews & the point about trying to convince the audience that this is some movie where you need to carry your brains to this movie , clearly means that Bharadwaj failed in his direction, his screenplay & editing departments for this movie. Since when did the knowledgeable Indian audiences tart needing movie critics to tell them what movie needs the audiences brains & what doesnt. Are the critics trying to say that , if the audiences failed to like this movie, it is probably because the audience didnt undertsand the plot, movie. Looks like its the new fad of using up names of some hollywood geniuses like Quentin Tarantino. Chaos,mayhem & lot of action doesnt mean it became a Quentin Tarantino kinda movie. Vishal Bharadwaj definitely failed in the city gangsta genre in this movie... & why go as far as to learn from Tarantino. Maybe Vishal needs to just take some lessons from Sanjay Gupta (Kaaante) & Ram Gopal Verma (Satya, Company, Sarkar) who have mastered the art of city ganster movies. The first half of the movie was like some slide show of all characters involved. Shahid Kapoor does very good & for one of his first action genre movies, he does great. Finally Priyanka Chopra has learnt to emote & she makes a valiant attempt.The supporting cast is good..specially Amol Gupte. Dhan te nan isthe highlight of the movie, surely catchy...the rest of the songs are average. But choreography wasnt upto mark. This movie surely is a big setback after a gem of a movie like Omkara from Vishal. Kaminey doesnt deserve any more than 3 stars for offering something different than the current lot of movies.

Posted by:  neelesh  [ Monday, August 17, 2009 2:19 AM ]
i dont know what is ur criteria of praising a film.. i saw it today.. its a complete mess and nothing to cheer about .. a story badly said..

Posted by:  sanchit  [ Monday, August 17, 2009 2:08 AM ]
Great movie - a must watch!The acting by one and all is excellent, especially Shahid Kapur.Loved him!Though I don't understand why it was rated A in India, I am sure it has something to do with the Shahid-Kareena-Saif and the fact that Saif's mother Sharmila Tagore is in the censor board that the movie got an A. The movie is not as gory as Ghajini and has no such steamy scenes as in most of the 'U' movies in Bollywood movies these days.Unfortunately, many will miss out on this extremely gripping and commercial movie because of this 'politically-contrived' A rating.A must watch!

Posted by:  abhishek  [ Monday, August 17, 2009 2:08 AM ]
worth a dekko..though confusing..but all characters well weaved..need to follow it intelligently to not to miss a jig..background score is tremendous which is generally the mainstay of this genre of films..acting is par excellence..non stop excitement though dark and serious..its no fun film..fun is in one liners and all the characters have it by way of their characterisation..humour is not forced..but its a great racy humour laced criminal caper..dhan..te..naaannn..fexy movie

Posted by:  aijaz  [ Monday, August 17, 2009 1:11 AM ]
Audience get to experience a world that has perhaps never been explored before in the Indian movies. The characters are introduced in the initial 30 minutes at the same time he has ensured that the twin brothers are not seen in the same frame till the interval.

Posted by:  arjun  [ Monday, August 17, 2009 12:44 AM ]
It was a nice movie. Had really good songs. Nice acting done by shahid and priyanka. It’s a must watch film.

Posted by:  GAUTAM KAUL  [ Monday, August 17, 2009 12:18 AM ]
KAMINEY is a disasterous movie. There can't be anything worse that can happen to the film industry. Every aspect of the movie was a blunder, and why the hell was the camera shaking so much....The ratings given by all sources, specailly NDTV is all fake. 4 star rating given here truly signifies the way media/all these channels media like ndtv etc cheat movie goers and strip them of their money. Bollywood is going to DOGS. Director and our great actor should take retirement and go for thirthyatra.

Posted by:  zack  [ Sunday, August 16, 2009 8:31 PM ]
Ridiculously lame, hopeless, terrible, pathetic.... I hope Shahid kapoor dies a slow and painful death. I will never again watch a movie which has Shahid Kapoor again, even if the actress strips naked in it...he copies Amitabh, Shahrukh and is a terrible actor. He looks damn cheap with those lame brown hair of his... And what happened to Bharadwaj?! How can it be the same guy who directed Omkara or Makdee...did he get high on drugs in the F-ing "GUITAR" and make the movie?! ...and I pity the people who find it hard to understand... Songs are either copied or boring...the "dhaan ta daan" song is totally influenced by "Pump it" by Black eyed peas... wasted my 8$ :(

Posted by:  Rajiv  [ Sunday, August 16, 2009 7:27 PM ]
Fhimply Fardard..!!

Posted by:  nasir  [ Sunday, August 16, 2009 6:47 PM ]
what a crap..i think our critics have lost the sense of movies.it is a dark movie with the slogans of jai mahrashtra and you concentrate on the movie in the mindless encounter..

Posted by:  Maku  [ Saturday, August 15, 2009 12:33 AM ]
xellent movie dudes n dudettes.... 1st half ws superb, 2nd hlf so-so... njoyd thoroughly...if u havnt gone 4 it 1st day, plz do go 4 it dis wknd...

Posted by:  sandeep  [ Saturday, August 15, 2009 12:28 AM ]
first half is so boring,i thought of literally going out of the hall but i stuck to it and 2nd half is ok..........overall movie i give 3 for 10...shahid acting is gud....i would say dont watch it..money waste.nothing else

Posted by:  prakriti  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 11:46 PM ]
i just watched this movie today and its really good! unlike any other bollywood movie..this movie will take u to a diff ride..smth u have never experienced it in a bolly movie..but ya in one of those guy ritchies movie. what an excellent direction, cinematography and acting by all these people. this movie will definetly need a lot of patience and intelligence to understand it. but guys its worrrrth it!!! anybody who doesnt like kaminey is plain borin...and who r just so used to watchin typical bolly love stories or whatever. i want to watch it again!! and u guys should watch it too!! i know audiences will have mixed reviews cause not a lot of people are used to watchin this movie... but i will tell u that this movie has lived up to its hype and expectations. its raw, funny, dark and intelligently potrayed. i loved it!! dhan te nannnnn

Posted by:  Ashwin  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 11:13 PM ]
Performances were great; but I feel the story could have had a better .

Posted by:  Ahmer Khan  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 11:09 PM ]
the finale alone is worth every buck you spend. it is just too good. vishal seems to be in love with first person shooters. its his tribute to video games. there's so many good things about the movie. its actually not everyone's cup of tea. you actually need to have some brains to keep track of the story. every character is as detailed as they can get. Everyone should go watch it. There's something for everyone.

Posted by:  raj  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 10:53 PM ]
in only one word jhakaaffffffff movie

Posted by:  Prashant Arya  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 9:33 PM ]
I fail to understand which taste is being referred to here by the critic. I have seen hollywood thrillers (crimson tide, training day etc etc) but this movie never had a grip. characters popped out from no where and plot was virtually non existant. In fact it looked like usual bolly wood drama, the only difference being that in the end all "kaminas" assembelled and got killed instead of being photgraphed as a happy joint family which lived happily ever after.

Posted by:  adish  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 9:15 PM ]
the movie is a bit difficult to comprehend but those who got it found the beauty of the movie ..true its very different n unlike our movies but yes these type of movies are the ones which take bollywood to another level n make film watching worthwhile......

Posted by:  Pranay P singh  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 9:00 PM ]
Well the movie is a real pain in head..guys go for 'Hangover' if u really wanna c class

Posted by:  Anurina  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 8:29 PM ]
Fatafati finema..........all the characters are so well defined and cast perfectly.......hats off to Vishal Bharadwaj........Shahid is awesome both as guddu and charlie.......Priyanka has also given a commendable perfomance ...........all in all i loved it......i thinks it defines a new genre of movies in india

Posted by:  priyanka  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 7:37 PM ]
owe some Movie.Shahid are looking realy hot in this movie its a super hit movie in this year. Owesome story and dialogues. Fuperhit movie (means Superhit)

Posted by:  Ramki  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 6:52 PM ]
Am om my way to watch the movie. Am excited.

Posted by:  Sachin Thakre  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 6:37 PM ]
The film is good but I didnt Enjoyed it. There was not a single scene in the entire film which was bit calm and relaxing...

Posted by:  Rajat  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 6:21 PM ]
Movie is good. Made in hollywood style. Plot confuses you but it all clears up at the end. Could have been better. Shahid is awesome. Priyanka is hot. The villians superb. But....there is no kamina in the movie. the title is a misnomer! P.S. A movie like Johny Gaddar should be titled Kaminey, not this bollywood potboiler.

Posted by:  baiju  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 6:01 PM ]
Very nice movie ...a must watch

Posted by:  Priyanjana  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 5:57 PM ]
The movie is one of the best i have seen. Both Shahid and Prianka are excellent in every way possible .. be it the dialouge delivery or their chemistry... Shahid as Charlie sizzled the screen.

Posted by:  grishma  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 5:43 PM ]
shahid is reaalllllly superb in the movie... i reallly loved it.... finally v got a movie which is different nd better dan those boring comedy movies made on pathetic subjects.....

Posted by:  sri  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 4:12 PM ]
movie is boring....

Posted by:  jay  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 4:04 PM ]
Dont watch it guys it is a boring movie. Just don't buy the ticket it's total money waste.

Posted by:  abhilash  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 3:56 PM ]
Awesome movie... and brilliant acting by sahid kapoor... dont miss the movie :D

Posted by:  shan  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 3:13 PM ]
Shahid performed excellent in this movie. I will give 5 stars out of 5

Posted by:  Aakash  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 2:55 PM ]
Interesting plot. Must see the movie. Thanks

Posted by:  Vikas  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 2:53 PM ]
I wasted my time...Maqbool, Onkara then Kaminey... I have a serious doubt that Mr. Bharadwaj has outsourced direction part of this movie to Ram Gopal Verma. My rating 2 ...Sorry Anupama je no offense..

Posted by:  Ajay  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 1:53 PM ]
A very partial review.

Posted by:  dhoondlo  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 1:03 PM ]
wonderful review..

Posted by:  Yesu  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 12:54 PM ]
Guys.. I am just out of the movie theatre.. I strongly recommend you to find out other ways of enjoying your weekend. There is nothing in this movie that you feel like you have enjoyed. The story and characters are all messed up. Though Shahid and Priyanka including all other characters have acted very well, the director has messed it up big time. He has failed to weave the story in a flow. You will find lots of boring patches in the 2 hours that you spend. It is neither an entertaining movie nor a marvellous piece of movie making. Avoid the movie and Have a happy weekend!!

Posted by:  Gagan Chadha  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 12:05 PM ]
Kaminey is quite a surprise movie to say the least. To me, Kaminey is not one movie, it is more than one movie. Its very unlike Bollywood and much like Hollywood. There are many stretches that one needs to follow and chances that you will fail in comprehending are quite high. I am not sure whether the movie will be hit(super hit). It might not perform well given that we don't have precendence established for such movies. I would personally like this movie to be a super hit. I want to watch this movie this again since the sound system in DT city center was not fantastic for the background score. Shahid has certainly come of age and this will be easily one of this best performances ever. He has been improving with each movie. First half, as mentioned above is quite boring(but you dont have to let this boredom reside in you) if you do, movie would be a flop for you. Follow the movie, the one liners are fantastic. The movie would be known for many reasons:the dark shades treated so well with a simple mannered Guddu..., S becoming F, Bhope/Tope/Tashi, Fhh ko Fhh nahi bolega to kya laa bolega, bengali/marathi/english dialects and use of these languages in the movie, Dhan te Tan.... Vishal Bhardwaj/Amole Gupte/Shahid/Priyanka - you rock!!! Go grab a watch if you do read this comment. -Gagan

Posted by:  Sarkar  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 11:51 AM ]
I am dying to watch this film... after Omkara let's see what does Vishal Bharadwaj has to offer us.

Posted by:  sumedha  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 11:23 AM ]
It is a good movie and I think Shahid is the best.

Posted by:  angad  [ Friday, August 14, 2009 10:57 AM ]
good movie

Latest Reviews
Striker
Harishchandrachi Factory
Rann
Ishqiya
  Veer
Chance Pe Dance
Pyaar Impossible
Dulha Mil Gaya
More »
Related Stories

Photos


More »
Videos


Will My Name Is Khan open on Friday in Mumbai?


Karan Johar meets police chief about SRK's film
More »
Talking Pictures


More »
More from this section
Specials
More »
NDTVMovies.com
celeb tweets
ADVERTISEMENT
NDTV Search