NDTV Search
Review : Billu
(Drama)
Anupama Chopra, Condulting Editor, Films, NDTV
Friday, February 13, 2009
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend Print A+   A-
Billu
Cast: Shahrukh Khan, Irrfan Khan, Lara Dutta, Kareena Ka
Director: Priyadarshan
Producer: Gauri Khan

Billu, the remake of the Malayalam blockbuster Kadhaparayumbol, is a contemporary Krishna-Sudama story.

Instead of a celestial being, we have a film actor, which is a fitting parallel in our celebrity-obsessed times. And instead of a poor Brahmin, we have a poor barber.

Billu, played by Irrfan Khan, lives in a UP village called Budbuda, He is a simple man leading a simple life, until a film unit arrives to shoot a futuristic film.

Why the director wanted to shoot an inter-galactic saga in a village is never explained but Bollywood throws Budbuda into a total tizzy. More so because Billu is a childhood friend of the film’s hero, superstar Saahir Khan, played by Shah Rukh Khan. Billu and Saahir inhabit different worlds. When their paths intersect, there is anguish, humiliation and ultimately redemption.

Kadhaparayumbol is propelled by emotions. The film’s poignance comes from the barber’s character - his acerbic tongue, his mouse-like insecurities and his sadness at being unable to give his family a better life. The superstar, played by Mammooty, has very little screen time. The star is seen as a distant, mythical creature whose charmed life fills the villagers with awe. Their passionate, reverential response to his stardom is a comment on celebrity and the relationship between stars and fans, especially in India.

Now, the advantage of casting Shah Rukh as a superstar is that the fact doesn’t need to be established. Shah Rukh Khan is short-hand for stardom. But director Priyadarshan and writer Mushtaq Sheikh spend way too much footage underlining this: there are three film-within-film songs with leading heroines and several gratuitous sequences, including one in which Saahir arrives in the village in a helicopter which has King Khan written on it.

The result is that we get little sense of Billu, his family or the other villagers, who play a critical role in the disruption of Billu’s life.

The village itself is a curious contradiction. It’s supposed to be in UP but the landscape is lush green Kerala interspersed with what looks like a studio-version of a small town chowk.

The villagers speak with various accents, the local school-teacher talks about parent-teacher conferences and in one sequence, we see a newsstand that sells Vogue magazine.

Detailing obviously isn’t Priyadarshan’s forte. He paints in broad strokes but at least in films like Bhool Bhulliya, he maintains a narrative momentum.

Billu is oddly staid and passionless, as if everyone involved was simply going through the motions.

The second half gathers some steam and the climax of the film is moving, but it is too little, too late. Billu remains a strictly average film, which given the talent involved, is disappointing. This one is for die-hard Shah Rukh Khan fans only.

Special: Billu

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend Print | A+   A-
Post your reviews
Name:*   E-mail:*
Comments:* 2000 characters remaining
 
Spam protection
Enter the code:*
Disclaimer: Material sent in this section is contributed by users. Ndtvmovies accepts no responsibility for the content or accuracy of such material and does not endorse or subscribe to the content.
User reviews


Posted by:  Subhajit ]
SRK lands in a unidentifiable machine from another planet on to another, then suddenly Deepika appears, so is one song. SRK has made sure that the entertainment quotient flows throughout the movie. And to most extent it does. When the movie was about to finish...it was again SRK who takes the centre stage. There are 4 songs in the movie. And who is there in all of them? Yes, again SRK. I mean we do need a break from him... And guess what? He gives you that break. And every now and then, there is one guy who keeps popping in to the screen and makes us sit and watch him closely. He delivers his dialogues with uncanny delicacy and sheer simplicity. Yet they are so powerful and moving that you will find yourself in tears when he finally chokes in the climax for just 10 seconds. Presenting the ultra talented Irfaan Khan in front of you, once again delivering a fine act. This is his movie, he holds the movie and he gives you the worth of your money. I wish Priyadarshan could have given him more time in the movie. The film is about two friends and how they finally met for just 5 minutes. The theme is nice, but I felt another director could have given this a different treatment. But Priyan Sir also pulled it off nicely. Lara has done a decent job. And again Mr. Priyadarshan has brought back his cast who are there with him for last 10 or more movies. Starting from Om Puri to Rajpal Yadav. Everyone has pulled off their own small part pretty nicely. Overall the movie is well shot with some nice locales, some unnecessary special effects and decent music from Pritam (his first for SRK). I would give an extra .5 for that one man who made the movie look better single-handedly. It's you Irfaan. Verdict: (2.5+ .5) 3 out of 5

Posted by:  rahul narain ]
tooooooooooooo gooooooooooood

Posted by:  Reuben Smile ]
Billu is a light, beautiful and realistic movie; just willingly suspend your disbeliefs. It's the plight of the integrity and innocence of a simpleton, efficiently enacted by Irfan. The film, besides the pathetic plight, cleverly portrays the hysterian way of life of the typical cinemaniac indian.

Posted by:  Sanjay ]
I think Billu is a very nice movie, especially Irfan Khan was fantastic as usual. But the best thing about the movie is Lara Dutta. She has given a wonderful performance inspite the fact that the movie was male-centric. Shahrukh, as usual crossed his limits. Now-a-days he doesn't act but over-act. All in all I'd say it's a nice movie, atleast some real time entertainment.

Posted by:  Pia ]
I LOVED THE MOVIE ...

Posted by:  k.c. chabookwala ]
This film has Irfan Khan playing a small town barber with big time connection. His friend is superstar SRK. That said, there is a limit to the extent, an age-old story can be milked without really trying. Thankfully, one song after the other helps cover up so-so acting and cookie cutter characters with walk-in parts. Big glitzy sets decorated with coloured plastic strips, hard currency and equally rare stupidity helps in creating the atmosphere of a village located on Mars or somewhere. Karina has now learnt the fine art of wardrobe selection and it shows in the amount of skin she displays. That should be enough for desperate weekend crowd. Irfan Khan delivers dialogue with such clarity, precision and emotion that most of his close friends might remain awake through out the film. As for others, the climax is rousing enough to wake up one and all. As the credit roll suggest, this is ‘filmed’ by Priyadarshan. So no one can be held responsible for direction, or lack of it. Music also plays the crucial part to keep the audience in a pleasant state of mental inertia. Story nuances are so sophisticated that you might question a conspiracy funded by depression prone grooming industry to promote shampoos, shaving creams and after-shave without the gullible audience knowing about it. At one point during the film (you might miss this if you don’t keep awake), Karina say that she loves all barbers irrespective of their size, shape, caste and creed and scissor size. So the national integration of these distant village people is cleverly taken care of. The film might as well get an award from National Barber Association of India. There is no guarantee though, because the editor has not used any ‘cutting’ technique! Dances are choreographed especially for Hollywood so the Indian audience need not complain. All is well that ends well, that is the message you get within minutes after the film starts. But don’t walk out just yet. A few popcorn packs will help you get though the

Posted by:  Amey ]
It's disater movie boaring than CC2C. SRK needs to retire now or else needs to do some meaningful role. LOL :)

Posted by:  khursheed khan ]
good movie srk again good prfm/.no dout about srk.he the best act. in bollybood but i like only one song/jarasi sawri he wo jara si bawri hae wo/khudaya khair

Posted by:  RAJESH ]
DON'T COMPARE WITH ORIGINAL BECAUSE EVERY CULTURE HAS DIFFERANT WAYS.SO YOU CAN'T COMPARE WITH MALAYALAM ORIGINAL AND HINDI REMAKE .

Posted by:  Sameer ]
I would seriously recommend people who love good cinema watch the Mallu version 'Kathaparayumbol'. Going in line with what Anupama has said, the original movie had been made with the story, the character of Balan (Billu) and his villagers forming the core of the movie. While in Billu, I too (no offense to anyone) felt that the movie was more about the celebrity. But then, looking at these things in another way, the kind of money that is spent on a Hindi movie vis-a-vis a Malayalam movie (budgets that are nothing compared to Hindi), stakes are higher for financiers in 'Bollywood' & therefore the movie having to work out is a more serious concern. So, the core-emphasis is to 'sell the product' and not just 'good cinema' & for this marketing is emphasized! and for that, what better way that King Khan himself!

Posted by:  yudhi ]
the difference between aamir and sharukh khan is that shahrukh does different roles in a same manner whereas aamir khan can do same role in different manner

Posted by:  Santosh ]
Irfaan Khan is the whole and soul of this movie. Watch it if you want to see Irfaan. Rest all is wasted.

Posted by:  Nayadi ]
Go and watch this movie..........only to lose money from your pocket...SRK, Pls retire from acting...Priyadarshan, Pls stop directing this kind of masalas (The malayalam version never looked like masala).....

Posted by:  Nayeem ]
I think this is the worst movie of Sharukh Khan,Priyadarshan should stop making films because he eithers copy a film or do a remake of south indian film,all his movies are remake like bhool bhuliya,billu barber,hungama,tere naam.For god sake stop remaking south indian movies.

Posted by:  Hareesh V R ]
Dear Priyan..The movie is so poor that its in no way matching with its malayalam version.. Yes..pepole can watch the movie just for a timepass.

Posted by:  YUDHISTER SINGH ]
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SHAHRUKH KHAN AND AAMIR KHAN IS THAT : SHARUKH DOES DIFFERENT ROLES IN SAME WAY , WHEREAS AAMIR CAN DO IN DIFFERENT WAY THE SAME ROLE SO I HOPE THIS MESSAGE IS CLEAR TO ALL SO CALLED BLIND FOLLOWERS OF ' "MR OVERHYPED MANNAT SHAHRUKH KARAN FARHA YASH JOHAR KHAN " A THIRD CLASS MOVIE TO SAY THE LEAST BY THIRD CLASS PERFORMERS FOR THIRD CLASS OF AUDIENCE I felt like ...Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you?

Posted by:  Chintan ]
Hi!! My name is Raj....Naam toh Suna Hoga!! Sun Sun ke pak gaya. "Hum ek baar jeete hain, Ek maar marte, Aur Pyar bhi ek bar hi hota hain"...Toh aisi picturein baar baar kyo banate ho. SRK please stop acting and stop spoiling the bollywood image abroad. Self Proclaimed "King" please have mercy on us. High time people start buying some meaningful cinema other than the typical dancing around trees with jazzy clothes and living in some dream world. When will good movies like 'A Wednesday' or 'Dasvidaniya' be made on a greater scale. SRK : - Seriously, please stop tarnishing Indias image abroad........Mein Canada mein kisko muh nahi dikha sakta!! Please have mercy SRK

Posted by:  Himanshu ]
No comedy,no drama,lots of songs and sheer waste of talent.Fully faltu film by Priyan.

Posted by:  Gauarv ]
I thing the Producer and Director of this film can end tish Biloo in 30 min they just whastage the 3 hours. And rest is is same as told by Anupama

Posted by:  Anoop ]
Waste of Money and time. Indian Cinema needs to learn a lesson from 'Slumdog Millionaire' and Movies by Aamir Khan. SRK is good for ONLY romantic indian masala.

Posted by:  Muhammed Javed ]
"Mera paisa doob gaya"

Posted by:  asht ]
The movie has its own charm, but overall dissappointing.

Posted by:  Deepak ]
I thnnk CC2C is better than ths, SRK gives these kind of movies in regular intervals like Bullshit badshah,duplicate, over acted in ram jaane and goes on with billu fully waste of money and time , beware of billu it sucks

Posted by:  Ginny ]
Secondly the ones who hate SRk pls dont watch his movies..but u do so i pity u guys...he does nt do similar roles but does more movies tham Aamir so it seems that he does one kind of movies..even aksahy does more movies so ppl think he does only comedy but he doesnt...he also does so many movies for nadiadwala n vipul shah..so does he belong to that camp...i dont think so..aamir has worked with ashutosh twice..hes worked with all the dir who were not first timers...he is star son..at least srk is not..he is self made like AB...even AB worked with same dir all the time during his time, shakti samant,manmohan desai,yash chopra to name a few...weell this movie is a sweet simple story.. SRK is loud coz he is required by the story to be..but not everyone understands that..Irrfan is brilliant..go watch it for simple delights of life..

Posted by:  Ginny ]
I would like to say few things for here before i get to the movie review...firstly when all u ppl shout abt srk and johars n chopras...do u realise that karan johar ws a first time dir when he made KKHH with SRk..so ws Aditya chopra when he made DDLJ..so ws Farah Khan when she made MHN..he works with first time dir n so its actually him who is making them hit not vice versa and secondly ppl from south stop comparing south indian movies with hindi movies coz te criteria is very diff for both south n north indian audiences..you guys worship Rajni but north indian ppl dont..so stop saying the original ws better coz ur taste is diff..

Posted by:  RAJ ]
its nice movie,Brilliant acting by srk & irfan.

Posted by:  Monideepa ]
Billu barber is rightly termed as short and sweet depicting of Krishna and sudama. Om puri played good role and so as Irfan khan. but story was not so nicely told by Priya.

Posted by:  jatin ]
well said anupama!!!! i totally agree with u.. point by point... word by word...

Posted by:  deepak ]
saw billu ,it was dissapointing film.its high time SRK does some meaning full roles like CHAK-DE,SWADES.now he has startrd looking old.

Posted by:  rahul ]
Ekdum bakwaas film. only Irrfan Khan is toletable because he has some acting skills. Self-Called 'King' Khan must do some acting at least at the end of his career. In this film SRK is as loud as he was in a film named 'Ramjane'. SRK requires cheap publicity like removing the name 'barber' from this film at the time of its release & the so-called attack on his illigally constructed home. It is a clear indication of his insecurity as a actor (?).

Posted by:  Sangeeta Bagwe ]
Average movie. 3 item songs!!! huge waste of the talented Om Puri - terrible "humour" scenes, (I felt sorry for him) and in one scene there's a prominent MARATHI calendar in Billu's house!! the "Mangal" for Tuesday is spelt in Marathi way, as that alphabet does not exist in Hindi. But Irrfan Khan, Lara Dutta & SRK are very good.

Posted by:  Amey ]
God Save me!!! Dam boaring and thirclass movie with superflop actor SRK. SRK's end has come to close now by doing this sort of films. I need my money back, where is the producer...?

Posted by:  sheetal ]
i truely cnt expecet ths frm king khan

Posted by:  nisha ]
no comparison with its original malayalam movie, it would have been better if the movie propelled by emotions. They should have learned experince from the Tamil remake.

Posted by:  Mathew ]
Billu barber is story of a poor barber and his struggle to meet his both ends and not a story about chitrahar of a super star. The back bone of the original movie kadhaparaymbol is the narration of friendship between a super star his friend Billu barber and his importance in his star dom. The dialog delivery and the word laced with emotions in such a manner that makes normal viewers eyes wet while watching the original movie which in turn makes a person feel they have seen a good movie about friendship. The whole story inter connected frame by frame with barber and the super star. The original movie barber is 90% and the super star is 10% and in copy billu barber, it is other way round. Advice to reader if you have seen billu barber see the original movie Kadhaparayumbol in DVD with English or Hindi sub title on and if you have not seen the original movie watch it, a beautiful tale of friendship and after this you will never have the gilt of buying pirate DVD’s of Bollywood movies

Posted by:  yudhister singh ]
if u see the career of shahrukh khan u will notice that he does films with only well known big directors like karan johar. yash -raj. secondly most of his films are with leading actresses like madhuri, kajol, rani. juhi, karishma and kareena and now deepika. he does same kind of roles and looks exactly same in all roles . he is stale and over acts. see his voice .and in all his films he will woo the lady who is either marrried to other guy or is to get married to other guy in the film. he in all roles will become pally with the actresses brother or sister or mother or friend. in my view he is most over hyped actor in indian film industry and is survivivng due to bhed chaal of indian people. we indians go after those personalities who are made by media . remember what happened when ravi shastri won champion of champion trophy? this guy lacks acting skills of aamir khan. aaamir khan dont go to award ceremonies dont attent wedding function and perform on stage like usa tours. can shahrukh can resist this media publicity? no i dont think so. he buys awards like filmfare. this movie is as usual pathetic. the attack on his house is gimmic to attract more guys watching his movie

Posted by:  Aman ]
I drove 100 Kms from Waterloo to Toronto to see Billu Barber. Either barbers will like or SRK Fans. Complete waste of time and money.

Posted by:  andy ]
super & super flop of 2009 skh s'have keep one thing in his mind his day's are over.pls do not waste your time to watch this movie

Posted by:  abc ]
not even for shahrukh fans the movie sucks. priyadarshan should stop making movies now

Posted by:  Amreen ]
I did not find anything great in this movie. Can say that itz only a one time watch movie. I think Lara and her kids were great. I did not like either of the Khans.Shahrukh Khan shows off lots of attitude.

Posted by:  Qadir ]
Really disappointing. I cant believe SRK can produce and agreed to such a bad edited and directed movie. Songs were out of sync but good and act of Irfan Khan. Rest nothing to watch for. Time waste movie...

Posted by:  ashish ]
i m disappointed..... only last 10 mins movie was gud and sum comic seens.....

Posted by:  Nidhi Saxesna ]
Its full faltoo movie with jatoo concept.its all for lover of sharukh

Posted by:  Jagat ]
I dont understand that what happened to our Actors and directors. Kya soch kar ye picture banate hain...

Posted by:  Mann ]
I don't understand when will people stop criticizing SRK and his movies.. why are they so jealous ...is it because of his fame or his charm...anyways grow up guys talk something that makes sense ... Billu is actually Irfan khan's film just look the way he portrayed his character,he is so natural...Film is so sweet,great story ...reminds of our old forgotten friends... don't criticize only because SRK produced it... If you like or you don't like SRK rocks n will always rock in whatever he does... Keep it up Shahrukh.... We love you n pray best for you.God bless all!!!

Posted by:  Bhanu ]
Whole movie is just another film story...nothing special about it.

Posted by:  gurinder gulati ]
It's an average film - except the end or the humility of Irrfan Khan - there is nothing very exciting

Posted by:  RAHUL SHARMA ]
I have seen this movie yesterday only.Irfan khan is great in the movie,but this over-actor(SHAH RUKH KHAN IS THE BIGGEST OVER ACTOR,WORLD CINEMA HAS EVER PRODUCED).He does'nt know how to act normally,or what controlled acting is all about.I saw kabhi haan kabhi na,and become his fan,but he overacted after that in every movie of his.We friends still saw all his movies,just because of KHKN.But now on we 17 friends swear,we'll never see his movies in our entire life.After OSO & RNBDJ and BILLU,he has showed the world,that he's the biggest over-actor of all the film industries of the world.How priyadarshan took this project and how come he directs this self proclaimed,king,badshah,no.1 brand,most fantastic actor.And when it comes to acting,even a street dog can give better expressions then him.He should forget his spinal surgery,he should go for the facial surgery,so that expressions can come out of those dead facial muscles.Please don't see his movies again,we all are making him the billionaire and most famous celebrity,without his talent and he does'nt deserve to be in this film industry.I warn u KING,BADSHAH OF OVER-ACTING,leave acting ,otherwise people will ask all the ticket amount,that they have spend on all your movies plus interest of that amount.

Posted by:  Sudipto Chakraborty ]
Billu Baber is really a moral tale.It carries simplicity,togetherness and emotions that placed the movie in right place. May be people can think its little extra screen presense of SRK. But i would say its is exact presense. Because if the movie depict more and more suffering side of billu and his stryggle it will be come bore and unwatchable. So movie did the right thing.. very beautifully depicted the struggle of billu also mixed the overwhelming and larger than life SRK. Songs are good so and swithching of the scenes from emotion and comedy of billu to SRK life is good..If it kept more time in billus emotion that it it will looks odd. SO Priyadarshan did right thing. Also using of character liek rajpal jadav,ompuri asrani is perfect we can't mor ethan that then again it will be boring. SO again Priyadarshan did right thing. Also for the story we don't need to know the geography of the Village ..its very colorfull that goes with that simple beautifull story.Songs are good. If you go to acting SRK is always can emotionaly so touchy. Great thing is Irfan the gifted actor get chance to show his skill at fullest credit goest to SRK to give him that space so much. Lara dutta also at her best. I think If you miss this movie then you going to miss one simple very earthy story from your heavy and complex life... Don't miss this oportunity to give your life to touch simplicity and love and smile. watch it. SRK always has great thought and great businessman as well.once again he proved he can cheers the crowd ..give them smile also pass good message: Never forget the person who knows you when you are nothing.....then u can shine.. SRK great job man..... I goes atleast 3+ with this SRK's such obidient attempt...with Priyadarshan.

Posted by:  vivek raj ]
i guess sharukh is not in his best avtar. i think film has some good performance like irfan, lara and ompuri. over all its an average movie. anupma as the critic did her job well. but i would request you should live your job for criticizing movie. why you compare this movie with original. if you are a critic then compare movie on other aspect like performances songs music masal and above all entertainment.

Posted by:  sophiya ]
Brilliant acting by both the "Khans." Go watch it!!1

Posted by:  Sunayna ]
Billu is a good movie with a simple storyline. The climax is wondeful. Irfan khan's performance is moving. A good watch.

Posted by:  mohammad hashim ]
Irfan`s performance is at par with the great Charlie Chaplin`s.He is a treat to watch. Lara Dutta should be praised for her great effort. Photography is excellent.Undoubtedly the movie is much above average and a sure fire hit.

Posted by:  Ashish ]
I think it was an average movie. One must the movie for imaculate acting of Irfan Khan. He's just added another fan in an already long list.

Posted by:  karthik ]
This should be the worst film by shah rukh. I recommend people to avoid this movie. After watching this picture you would feel your money flown down the drain

Posted by:  Manu ]
Simple and a very well made movie with excellent performances.

Posted by:  rahul roy ]
great movie best that has come in years.must watch 4 everyone who enjoys good movies,not only 4 srk fans and one thing this one is better than the orginal one

Posted by:  abhishek ]
True ..the title is ...Billu barber....i have not seen the movie yet..as i am a die hard hater of SRK....as heared the movie is just a publicity stunt of SRK , a result of KHAN vs KHAN ... he has used the movie just to show is image as a mega star..for such a movies based on emotion..what was the use of incuding item nos...what was the use of showcasing SRK as a larger than life persona and adding so many heroins....for many past movie we have been seeing SRK in youth roles..he dances..he flashes is body now..same repeatation of yash chopra and KARAN johar's films like scenes... Come on SRK give us some sensible films... About GAZINI..it was declared in the bigining that it is an out and out thriller and the whole file was like that only...the 8 packs of Amir was also justified and it was not showed off in the movie unnecessalily here and there... so Mr SRK come out of ur Romantic roles give us something that we can rememba for long like we rememba tare zameen par and lagan.. in shuch a movie where the emotions sd be highlighted and promoted more..u are promiting only ur stature..just stop this childish and foolish act....this is one of the reason RSK does not have any respect in masses as Amir and AB have...pple only treat him as a entertainer not a larger than life and down to earth - Amir like actor and person..

Posted by:  ask ]
Excellent movie, Very simple and non melodramatic. Irfan is superb and Shahrukh has played himself. Few hiccups ,otherwise a good film.

Posted by:  Ayush Johry ]
It's these kinds of movies and these actors like Shahrukh Khan who know nothing but glamour, destroy bollywood's image abroad.

Posted by:  prasad ]
This is a ramake of tamil version in which Rajani kanth played...which is again a remake in which Mamoothy playes the super star. This is a flop movie....

Posted by:  Rajat juneja ]
BILLU is an excellent movie..awesome acting by irfan,Srk..

Posted by:  Prem ]
Sucks

Posted by:  Sri Ram ]
the movie should have been called Billu aur Ullu..what a pathetic movie..they have killed the very spirit of Kadhaparayumbol.

Posted by:  Jahid ]
Worst movie.

Posted by:  Deep ]
I guess there is no problem if a lush green village is shown..I felt the film has some great performance by Irfan Khan, Om Puri and various other characters.

Posted by:  umesh ]
looks like another movie in the list of flops from biggies....

Posted by:  Shinesh, Bahrain ]
The film lacks screenplay

Posted by:  rs ]
Dear Abhay, First of all, it is a remake, so comparisons are bound to be; secondly priyadarshan is like a parasite more than anything, the guy has absolutely no talent or creativity, he just feeds on other's ideas, only genuine talent will be praised, the rest can make money but dont expect anything else unless you have genuine talent and not copying others ideas.....

Posted by:  abhishek ]
in agreement..a very average affair..irfaan khan is good though...

Posted by:  Shri ]
Good Review by Anupama Chopra.responding on remakes people do compare the original.I believe unless comapred you wouldnt knw how well the same theme has worked.for ex:Ghajini ppl down south dint like it as Surya(Tamil Actor)did a better job in Tamil.So Ghanjini was for sure for North Audience.Same again for Billu if it wasnt a SRK Movie ppl wont get the hype needed to go and watch.Also SRK is no doubt banking on a already hit formula so the losses are minimal.SRK seriously need to experiment in different roles thn the usual Chopra's n Johars camp.I totally agree Billu is a strict n exclusively for die hard SRK fans only.

Posted by:  John Kapoor ]
Shahrukh Khan has said from the start that this film isn't his film, but Irrfan Khan and Lara Dutta's. He's mentioned this in every interview, and by now it's common knowledge that he simply has an extend guest appearance. And yet, how many times was Irrfan mentioned in this review? 1. Lara? 0. Is the reviewer, Anupama Chopra, really so stupid that she didn't realize this? The review seems to make it out like Shahrukh not only had the lead role, but also wrote and directed it (Priyadarshan is mentioned just once as well). And the last line, "this is for die-hand SRK fans only". UM, IT'S NOT A SHAHRUKH KHAN FILM! It's like judging Luck By Chance solely on Hrithik's appearance or Salaam Namaste by Abhishek Bachchan's. Regardless of how the film is, it should at least be seen in the right light! If it's not, I don't see any reason why anyone who reads this review shouldn't discount it.

Posted by:  abhay ]
dear critic I don't know why you compare any remake with original. If you are a critic just analyse a film in various aspects of film making like editing, music, acting etc.... there can be several ways of presetation of same story...at the end it should appeal..... any how i am going to see this movie as directed by priyadarshan and brilliant cast appearence. abhay

Latest Reviews
A Christmas Carol
Kurbaan
2012
Aao Wish Karein
  Tum Mile
Jail
Ajab Prem ki Gazab Kahani
Aladin
More »

Photos


More »
Videos


'Abhay, I get along very well'


Shilpa, Raj's wedding today
More »
Talking Pictures


More »
More from this section
Specials
More »
NDTVMovies.com
ADVERTISEMENT
NDTV Search