HomeMovie Reviews

Shivaay Movie Review: Ajay Devgn's Film is a Misfire of Himalayan Proportions

Shivaay is obviously Ajay Devgn's film all the way - he is in virtually every frame

  | December 06, 2016 11:19 IST


<i>Shivaay</i> Movie Review: Ajay Devgn's Film is a Misfire of Himalayan Proportions
  • Genre:
    Action, Thriller
  • Cast:
    Ajay Devgn, Sayyeshaa Saigal, Erika Kaar, Abigail Eames, Vir Das, Girish Karnad, Saurabh Shukla
  • Director:
    Ajay Devgn

Random indeed are the ways of Shivaay, both the film and the character. The hero knows no limits. He leaps off snow-capped cliffs and slithers down steep mountains with the ease of a boy swatting flies.

Likewise the film. It stops at nothing. One brief exchange sums up Shivaay perfectly. The Bulgarian heroine asks the titular protagonist: "Shivaay with a y. Why." Exactly our question.

The hero's reply is curt and casual: "Why not?" True. Shivaay dangles between many such whys and why nots.

In the second half, an Indian embassy girl decides to throw her lot behind the hero when the latter finds himself on the wrong side of the Bulgarian law after his eight-year-old daughter is kidnapped by the Russian mafia.

Abigail Eames in Shivaay

Her garrulous boss, the ambassador to Sofia, reasons with the greenhorn: Why are you doing this? Life is never like a 30-page comic book.

The girl, whose mind is firmly made up, retorts with all the wisdom at her command: "Comics ki duniya ke baahar superheroes bahut kam milte hain, Sir." So, there.

The man called Shivaay is a superhero all right, and he is trapped in a comic-strip world of make-believe where narrative logic is as rarefied as the Himalayan air he breathes.

In fact, with Ajay Devgn not only acting but also directing, Shivaay is Singham (minus the khaki uniform) transported to Sofia and the Balkan mountains.

The hero is an intrepid, unstoppable, super-skilled Himalayan mountaineer and trek guide. No calamity, no avalanche, no snowstorm, no adversary can deflect him from his path.

Ajay Devgn in Shivaay

And when push comes to shove, he turns into a full-blown Rambo-esque fighter who sends the Russian mafia and corrupt elements in the Bulgarian police scurrying for cover.

The Shivaay screenplay is predicated on a weak, arbitrary premise. The hero falls for a Bulgarian girl Olga (Polish actress Erika Kaar). But he is in no mood to accompany her to her homeland. "Shivaay Himalaya ke siva nahin jee sakta," he tells her rather airily.

But the brief encounter leaves Olga pregnant. Shivaay seizes upon that turn of events and insists that he now wants to have something that he has never had - a family.

Ajay Devgn and Erika Kaar in Shivaay

So he pleads with the visitor to stay on until the birth of the baby. She does, paving the way for the crisis that drives the cool climber over the edge in the second half of the choppy 172-minute film.

Plenty of blood is spilled. The body count is high. And there are car chases galore through the streets of Sofia and the mountain highways of Bulgaria.

But the father-daughter relationship, the focal point of the film, does not rise to any great heights. It fails to evoke genuine emotion.

In fact, none of the characters develop into rounded, believable people. Their motivations are hazy, their actions arbitrary.

In the end, Shivaay, for all its flashy action scenes, is as perfunctory as the mechanical lip-lock between the male lead and the Polish actress impersonating a Bulgarian who spouts fully rounded Hindi sentences.

If their passion hadn't been triggered in an improbable setting - a transparent tent hanging precariously in a crevice between two mountain ledges - it would have counted as just another screen kiss.

But here we are before "an extraordinary man in extraordinary circumstances". So expect far-out miracles.

The film (screenplay and dialogue: Sandeep Shrivastava) takes the concept of falling in love rather too literally. When a life-threatening snow slip strikes a band of high-altitude trekkers, Shivaay and Olga plunge off the face off an icy mountain - and live to tell the tale.

A still from Shivaay

But that is only one of many falls that the film suffers. The brave, upright mountaineer, on learning that his one-stand stand has impregnated the pretty damsel, makes his bizarrely unreasonable demand.

The woman, on her part, asserts that she wants to live her own life and refuses to hitch herself to Shivaay for good.

So, the man is left holding the baby. Eight years later, his spirited deaf-mute daughter, Gaura (British child actor Abigail Eames), is the centre of his universe.

Ajay Devgn and Abigail Eames in Shivaay

When father and daughter set out in search of the absent mother and land in Sofia, they encounter big trouble at every turn.

They run into a gang of child traffickers in the business of selling kidnapped girls and boys to organ smugglers and flesh traders.

The audience is informed that the Russian mafia is a ruthless bunch. So well-oiled is their operation that 72 hours is all that they need to bundle their captives into a van and drive them across the Bulgaria-Romania border.

So our hero has very little time to play with. With some help from the Indian envoy in Sofia (Saurabh Shukla), "a Bihari from Motihari", and this spunky embassy rookie Anushka (Sayyeshaa Saigal), who develops a soft corner for the wronged father, he goes after the bad guys.

The baddies are real bad and they answer to names like Nikolai, Ustinov and Ivanovic. But no matter how weighty their monikers, they are obviously no match for Shivaay.

It takes the film nearly three hours to establish that obvious fact. By which time you are too tired to even think.

The actors in the supporting cast - Abigail, Erika, Sayyeshaa, and even Vir Das playing an ethical hacker whose services are enlisted by Shivaay - do their bit to be noticed, but no more.

Shivaay is obviously Ajay Devgn's film all the way - he is in virtually every frame. His body tattooed with the lord's locks, serpent and trident, he is Shiva's own man on earth.

Ajay Devgn in Shivaay

He smokes a chillum, sports earrings and looks as if he is always on an acid trip. His fans will have absolutely no reason to feel shortchanged. But the film doesn't propel itself anywhere close to ending on a high.

In a philosophical mood, Shivaay advises Olga that a relationship shouldn't be measured by the number of days it lasts, but by the number of breaths.

Climb down to a more mundane plane and try judging Shivaay by the number of yawns and yelps of disbelief it induces. You will lose count pretty quick.

Visually, there is much going for this film, especially with cinematographer Aseem Bajaj making the most of the striking Balkan canvas and painting breathtakingly pretty pictures on it.

But Shivaay is a misfire of Himalayan proportions.

Watch Trailer:

Listen to the latest songs, only on